A comparison among various wireless technologies for data transmission in ISM frequency band :-
Parameter
|
Bluetooth
|
Zigbee
|
RF
|
Wi-Fi
|
Range
|
10 - 100 m
|
10 -100 m
|
~500m
|
~1000 m or
|
Data transmission rate
|
~2 MBPS
|
~250 KBPS
|
~500 KBPS
|
~100 MBPS
|
Power Consumption
|
~100 mW
|
~250 mW
|
~100 mW
|
~500 mW
|
Current consumption
|
~60 mA
|
~190 mA
|
10 - 50 mA
|
~250 mA
|
Minimum receiving power
|
-95 dBm
|
-100 dBm
|
-120 dBm
| |
A comparison among various available RF module/IC :-
Part No.
|
Tx - Power (dBm)
|
Rx - Power (dBm)
|
Current consumption (mA)
|
Range (m)
|
Data Transmission rate
|
Operating Frequency (MHz)
|
Price
(Rupees)
|
Protocol supported
|
Special Feature
|
RFM22/3B
|
+20/+13
|
-121
|
85/30 18.5
|
600
|
256 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
800 (module)
|
RF
|
LBD & TS
|
SPIRIT 1
|
+11/+16
|
-118
|
21 9
|
200
|
500 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
160 (IC)
|
RF
|
LBD & TS
Carrier sns
whitening
|
TC32306FTG
|
+10
|
-116
|
12 9.7
|
00
|
ISM band
|
300(IC)
|
RF
| ||
LE-50-433/868
|
14
|
-109
|
45 26
|
2000
|
115.2 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
RF
| ||
nRF24L01+
|
0
|
-82
-85
-94
|
11.3 13.5
|
50
|
2 MBPS
1 MBPS
250 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
250
|
RF
| |
MRF89XAM9A
|
+10
|
-105
-111
|
25 3
|
100
|
25 KBPS
2 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
500(module)
|
RF
| |
SiFLEX02-R2
|
24
|
-102
|
285 30
|
3200
|
40 KBPS
|
900 MHz
|
3000(module)
|
RF &
Zigbee
|
With antenna
|
TarangF4L
|
0
|
-92
|
45 50
|
250 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
RF &
Zigbee
|
With antenna
| ||
Xbee
|
45 50
|
30
|
~250 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
1000(module)
|
Zigbee
| |||
MDBT40
|
+4
|
-93
|
16 12.6
|
80
|
250 KBPS
|
ISM band
|
500(module)
|
BLE
| |
nRF51422
|
+4
|
-93
|
10.5 13
|
100
|
2 MBPS
|
ISM band
|
1000 (module)
|
BLE
| |
HC06
|
+6
|
-80
|
40 30
|
50
|
2 MBPS
|
ISM band
|
300(module)
|
BLE
| |
EMB-TRX169PA
|
+27
|
-122
|
385 27
|
>500
|
200 KBPS
|
169 MHz
|
(module)
|
RF
|
External antenna rqd
|
LBD : Low Battery Detection
TS : Temperature Sensor
No comments:
Post a Comment